European markets edge higher
With Spanish shares recovering despite the continuing tensions between the government and Catalan separatists, European markets managed to end the day higher. The exception was Germany, which slipped back from its record highs. In the UK, a weakening pound gave some support to the FTSE 100, dominated as it is by overseas earners who benefit from a fall in sterling. The final scores showed:
- The FTSE 100 finished 40.41 points or 0.54% higher at 7507.99
- Germany’s Dax dipped 0.02% to 12,968.05
- France’s Cac closed up 0.3% to 5379.21
- Italy’s FTSE MIB rose 0.49% to 22,566.03
- Spain’s Ibex ended up 2.51% at 10,214.7
- In Greece, the Athens market slipped 0.79% at 744.80
On Wall Street, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is currently up 91 points or 0.4%, ahead of Friday’s non-farm payroll numbers.
On that note, it’s time to close for the day. Thanks for all your comments, and we’ll be back tomorrow.
Over in Spain, the stock market has recovered much of Wednesday’s slump, as Spain rules that Catalan’s parliament should be suspended on Monday, thus ruling out an expected vote on independence. David Madden, market analyst at CMC Markets UK, said:
The IBEX 35 is the best performer in Europe, which make a nice change seeing the Spanish market lost the most ground this week. Madrid and Catalonia are still at loggerheads, and the Spanish government has suspended Catalan’s parliamentary session which was due to take place on Monday. Only the Parliament of Catalonia can declare independence, and since Madrid has prevented the meeting from taking place there isn’t much the separatists can do. Nonetheless, investors will be fearful of the Spanish stock market while the Catalan question hangs over the country.
The pound’s weakness against the dollar could be temporary, suggests John Higgins at Capital Economics:
Although sterling has fallen sharply against the dollar over the past fortnight or so, we forecast that the exchange rate will end this year and next at $1.35/£, above its level now of $1.31/£.
Sterling’s drop on Thursday appears to have been prompted by unexpectedly-weak car sales in the UK..and growing doubts over PM Theresa May’s future. The economy as a whole seems to be holding up quite well, though. And we don’t expect it to be derailed by political uncertainty unless we end up with a new prime minister with a markedly-different view of how Brexit negotiations should proceed.
That risk aside, sterling’s exchange rate against the dollar will probably continue to be driven by shifting views of monetary policy. Expected interest rates shot up in the UK in mid-September after the MPC signalled that it might raise Bank Rate sooner than investors had expected. But expected interest rates then rose further in the US after the FOMC’s meeting later in the month, when participants’ projections suggested that a hike in the federal funds rate in December remains on the cards.
This helps to explain why a fall of more than 2% in the dollar against sterling between these two policy meetings has since been more than unwound. Other “majors” have still fared worse than sterling against the US currency since the MPC’s last meeting, though.
We think that the contrast between policy rates in the US and UK at the end of next year will be a bit starker than investors appear to be anticipating. Our view is that the gap will be minus 1.00-1.25 percentage points (pp), which reflects forecasts of 2.25%-2.50% for the US and 1.25% for the UK.
The gap implied by our forecasts for policy rates would be broadly consistent, on the basis of past form, with a slightly weaker dollar/sterling exchange rate than the one that we are projecting. But the difference is not large. And we suspect that the exchange rate will find some support late next year from the prospects for monetary policy in 2019. We forecast that the gap in policy rates will shrink to minus 0.75-1.00pp during that year, as the Fed’s tightening cycle ends in the spring while the MPC’s continues gradually.
Connor Campbell, financial analyst at Spreadex said:
Sterling’s suffering was exacerbated this afternoon by a beefed up showing from the dollar.
Cable plunged as much as 0.9% this Thursday, dragging the pound to a sub-$1.325 4 week nadir against the greenback. Sterling also maintained a half a percent drop against the euro – which itself fell 0.3% against the dollar – sporadically causing the pound to dip below €1.12, a level it hasn’t seen since mid-September.
As has been the case all day, there isn’t any one great defining factor either driving the pound lower or the dollar higher, but rather a web of news items highlighting the impact of Brexit uncertainty for the former and suggesting a hawkish Fed for the latter. Cable is likely to remain the dominant force on Friday, as investors gear up for a potentially crucial (and likely hurricane hit) set of non-farm figures.
US factory goods orders rise
Still with the US, and factory goods orders rose by more than expected in August.
New orders increased by 1.2%, following a 3.3% drop recorded in July and better than the forecast 1% rise. On the recent hurricanes the Commerce department said: “We cannot isolate the effects of Hurricanes Harvey and Irma on either the Advance Report or Full Report on Manufacturers’ Shipments, Inventories and Orders, because the survey is designed to estimate the month‐to‐month change in manufacturing activity at the national level and not at specific geographic areas.”
Updated
Wall Street opens higher
US markets are continuing their winning streak.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average is up 12 points in early trading while the S&P 500 and Nasday Composite have opened at new record highs.
S&P 500 opens at record high, on track for its longest winning streak since 1997 https://t.co/mic6Gtuxvq pic.twitter.com/Br7NzzlsDG
— CNBC (@CNBC) October 5, 2017
Williams however will not vote on interest rates this year, so if they do rise in December it will not be down to him:
Other voters next year are Mester (hawk), Bostic (unknown/centrist), and the head of the Richmond Fed who don't have a President yet
— RANsquawk (@RANsquawk) October 5, 2017
The dollar of course is being supported by the expectation of a US rate rise before the end of the year. And new comments from San Francisco Fed president John Williams in a speech in Missouri do little to dispel that idea:
SF Fed Gov Williams: "As inflation rises and the economic expansion continues, we will be able to move rates up to their new normal level"
— Sigma Squawk (@SigmaSquawk) October 5, 2017
The pound is on track for its worst week against the dollar since November 2016, according to Reuters.
Pound drops to four week low against the dollar
The pound continues to fall, now down a cent or 0.8% against the dollar at $1.3135.
The UK currency is now at its lowest since early September and has lost all the gains (and more) that it made after the Bank of England suggested rates might rise in November.
Worries about a challenge to Theresa May as UK prime minister following her conference speech has unsettled investors, since a weakened leadership is hardly ideal for the crucial Brexit negotiations.
The latest poor economic data - in the shape of disappointing car sales - also point to an economy which would struggle to accommodate increased borrowing costs. Indeed, ratings agency S&P suggested that very thing this week.
Meanwhile the strong US data - service sector on Wednesday, jobless claims now - is helping to push the dollar higher.
Updated
US jobless claims fall by more than expected
Over in the US, and weekly jobless claims have come in better than expected.
Ahead of the non-farm payrolls numbers tomorrow, the Labor Department said the number of Americans filing for unemployment benefits fell by 12,000 last week to 260,000. Analysts had been expecting a figure of around 265,000. But the impact of the recent hurricanes makes the picture a little difficult to assess. The department said: “Hurricanes Harvey, Irma, and Maria impacted this week’s claims.”
Dennis de Jong, managing director of UFX.com, said:
President Trump will be quick to point towards the strength of the labour market on the back of today’s positive jobless claims data. The initial impact of hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria have typically increased the number of new applications for unemployment benefits. However, today’s dip dampens fears of job growth restraint in the coming months.
Initial jobless claims are unlikely to return to August’s record lows for a while yet, though. Weekly claims had previously been operating at their lowest level since the early 1970s, but with many businesses yet to reopen in the wake of the natural disasters, a number of Americans are still faced with little choice but to seek unemployment benefits.
Here’s a nice chart from the BBC, showing how diesel’s share of UK car sales has shrunk, while electric vehicles are carving out a bigger slice of the market.
Why we are ditching diesel and cutting back on car-buying.Six charts that tell the story https://t.co/gigixSzimS pic.twitter.com/ZL6Kd7YBtX
— Brian Milligan (@brianmilli) October 5, 2017
Rebecca Long-Bailey MP, Labour’s Shadow Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, says the drop in UK car sales is part of a wider problem:
“This is an economy being driven into the ditch. Sales of cars last month were down 9.3 per cent compared to a year earlier.
This is worrying not only for the car industry but speaks to a deeper economic malaise with anaemic economic growth figures this year and real wages lower than ten years ago. The country desperately needs a bold, transformative industrial strategy which only a Labour government will deliver.”
This chart shows one reason why Britain’s economy is in a mess - productivity has been persistently weak since the financial crisis, repeatedly defying forecasts of growth.
For 7 years, OBR have said productivity is set to increase.
— Joe Dromey (@Joe_Dromey) October 5, 2017
For 7 years it has defied predictions and flat-linedhttps://t.co/PidZpVCAYT pic.twitter.com/UnTTrmVzVJ
FT: Hammond's war chest is shrinking
The decline in car sales highlights the pressure on chancellor Philip Hammond to deliver an impressive budget next month.
The government desperately needs something to cheer about, following the debacle of Theresa May’s speech yesterday. Hammond could improve the mood with some growth-friendly policies, tax cuts or spending pledges.
Abolishing the public sector pay cap, for example, might give the Tories a boost.
But there’s a problem. Britain’s economy has only expanded slowly this year, so Hammond has less wriggle-room than previously expected. Weak GDP growth means the UK’s official fiscal watchdog may revise down its assessment of the UK economy.
That would wipe out much of the £26bn which the chancellor set aside for a rainy day in 2016’s autumn statement.
Chris Giles, economics editor of the Financial Times, reckons that two-thirds of Hammond’s war chest has been wiped out. He writes:
Philip Hammond is facing what officials describe as “a bloodbath” in the public finances in his Budget next month as weak economic forecasts derail the government’s plans.
As much as two-thirds of the £26bn of headroom in the public finances that the chancellor created last year as a buffer for the economy through the Brexit period is likely to be wiped out after the government’s fiscal watchdog concludes its forecasts for growth have been too optimistic.
The Office for Budget Responsibility will publish on Tuesday a new analysis suggesting it has persistently over-estimated Britain’s productivity over the past seven years and will give a broad hint that it will rectify the situation with a more pessimistic Budget forecast.
Slower growth in the forecast will limit deficit reduction and cut the size of the war chest that Mr Hammond put aside to smooth the Brexit transition. This leaves him in an awkward position politically, since he is under increasing pressure to end the austerity cap on public pay, lower the burden of debt on students and build houses.
Just when you thought it couldn't get any worse...Eeyore Giles has got more bad news.
— malcolmmoore (@MalcolmMoore) October 5, 2017
Updated
Sales of new vans in the UK also fell in September, by over 4%, indicating that British businesses are cutting back.
The Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders reports that:
- Demand for new vans declines -4.2% in September to 57,368 units.
- Pickups and heavier van demand broadly stable, rising 0.4% and 0.1% respectively.
- Year-to-date registrations drop -3.1% overall, as business confidence dented.
SMMT chief Mike Hawes says:
Business confidence has taken a hit recently as economic and political uncertainty continues, so fluctuations in purchasing patterns are to be expected.
Updated
The 21% slump in diesel car sales has been welcomed by Friends of the Earth, the environmental campaign group:
Good consumers are turning away from diesels. Reports show diesel vehicles only marginally better on CO2 than petrol + far worse on NOx. https://t.co/uNADQCVoSW
— Friends of the Earth (@wwwfoecouk) October 5, 2017
Conversely, sales of electric cars jumped by 41% in October, from 16,000 to over 22,000. Alternatively fuelled cars now make up 5.4% of the market.
Umunna: Car sales decline is very concerning
Labour MP Chuka Umunna says the decline in UK car sales shows that Britain’s exit from the EU is causing significant harm to the UK ecnoomy.
“This is yet more evidence that Brexit is having a serious and damaging impact on our economy and on the livelihoods of the British people. Higher inflation, lower growth and greater uncertainty are all taking their toll. These new figures suggest that households are feeling the pinch.
“Car sales tend to be a barometer for the overall health of our economy, which makes this news even more concerning.
“The Government has a duty to put our economy and living standards first in the Brexit negotiations. That is why they should end their ideological red lines, give people and businesses certainty, and abandon their plan to leave the Single Market and the Customs Union.”
Car sales decline: What the experts say
Ian Gilmartin of Barclays Corporate Banking says the 9.3% slump in car sales in September was a poor result, but not unexpected given the drop in consumer confidence.
New plate months are always crucial, and some were pinning their hopes on the usual biannual boost providing a bit of respite ahead of further tough times, but that hasn’t materialised.
The result isn’t a surprise because across a number of retail sectors consumers are understandably becoming more reluctant to commit to high value purchases. Add to that the ongoing confusion over diesel models, which posted a 22% drop last month, and it’s easy to see why the overall figures have dipped so much.
Sue Robinson, director of the National Franchised Dealers Association (NFDA), says worries over diesel’s future are partly to blame.
“Consumers walking into the showroom need more clarity on issues such as diesel and air quality. We are working closely with car retailers to assist them in educating their customers.”
Andy Bruce of Reuters points out that motor retailers have warned that business conditions have deteriorated:
Very weak car registrations data add to signs that the auto market has slowed sharply #economy #BoE pic.twitter.com/JxkyvWSThR
— Andy Bruce (@BruceReuters) October 5, 2017
Nissan managed to beat Ford to the top of the best-sellers table last month:
Chris Bosworth, director of strategy at Close Brothers Motor Finance, says anxiety over the UK’s exit from the EU has hurt demand for cars.
September traditionally delivers a peak as the new registration plates are introduced, but it appears that the motor industry is struggling to shake off the impact that Brexit uncertainty is having on consumer spending.
We are already seeing the consequences of the weak pound on UK manufacturers’ profit margins, and this has made it difficult for dealers to offer customer deals, especially the 0% finance offers which would have been abundant in previous years.
Here’s a handy chart showing how UK car sales have declined this year:
UK new car registrations: change in the last six months, compared to the same six months last year. 📉🚗 pic.twitter.com/MqSf1qOpxh
— Mike Bird (@Birdyword) October 5, 2017
Diesel sales slump again
Diesel car sales slumped by over 20% in September, as British drivers continue to shun them following recent emission scandals.
Around 170,000 new diesel cars were registered last month, down from almost 218,000 in September 2016.
That follows the revelation that Volkswagen had used ‘cheat software’ to make their cars seem less polluting.
The SMMT claims that this trend is “thwarting the ambitions of both industry and government to meet challenging CO2 targets”.
SMMT warns after 21.7% fall in September diesel sales, if negative trend continues UK CO2 levels from new cars could rise this year
— Julia Kollewe (@JuliaKollewe) October 5, 2017
That’s because diesel cars emit less greenhouse gases than petrol models. However, they also emit toxic nitrogen oxides, which cause tens of thousands of deaths each year
A crackdown on older, more polluting diesel cars is now underway - London is introducing a new emissions charge to deter them entering the capital.
The value of used diesel cars has fallen sharply in recent months, as consumers worry that some cities could ban them altogether....
The decline in car sales last month was wide-ranging. Businesses bought 5.2% fewer cars, sales to private buyers fell 8.8%, while ‘fleet’ sales dropped by 10%.
Sales of luxury saloons slumped by over a third, while supermini sales dropped by 21%.
The slump in September sales means that new car registrations have fallen by 3.9% since the start of 2017.
Unless the market picks up, we could see the first drop in annual sales since the last recession.
Updated
It's official: UK car sales shrank in September
BREAKING: Car sales across the UK fell by 9.3% in September.
That’s the sixth monthly decline in a row, and raises the real risk that British car registrations post their first annual decline since 2011.
The Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders blames a fall in consumer confidence, due to “economic and political uncertainty” and confusion over the government’s air quality plans
As this charts shows, it’s the first decline in September sales in six years.
Mike Hawes, SMMT Chief Executive, said,
September is always a barometer of the health of the UK new car market so this decline will cause considerable concern. Business and political uncertainty is reducing buyer confidence, with consumers and businesses more likely to delay big ticket purchases.
The confusion surrounding air quality plans has not helped, but consumers should be reassured that all the new diesel and petrol models on the market will not face any bans or additional charges. Manufacturers’ scrappage schemes are proving popular and such schemes are to be encouraged given fleet renewal is the best way to address environmental issues in our towns and cities.
More to follow....
Pound hits three-week low
Sterling has hit a three-week low against the US dollar, shedding half a cent to just $1.318.
Fresh speculation over Theresa May’s future, ongoing Brexit worries, and today’s weak car sales are all weighing on the pound.
Alberto Gallo, head of macro strategies at Algebris Investment, blame the prime minister’s nightmare speech yesterday:
It has taken two speeches, but Theresa May has finally managed to undo Carney's attempt to prop up the Pound#Brexit #SoundAsAPound pic.twitter.com/uR499NTMCi
— Alberto Gallo (@macrocredit) October 5, 2017
Connor Campbell of SpreadEx says there is plenty of bad news chipping away at the pound.
There were the lingering effects of Standard & Poor’s comment yesterday stating that it is ‘sceptical’ of a Bank of England rate hike.
Keeping with the BoE, deputy governor Sam Woods argued that a transition deal with the EU would need to be in place before Christmas to prevent an exodus of City jobs out of the UK.
Then there was the report that car sales may have fallen 10% in September, leaving the UK industry on track for its first annual decline since 2011.
Sofa maker DFS: Very challenging furniture market
Britons are cutting back on new sofas, as well as new cars, it seems.
Furniture maker DFS just posted a 22% drop in pretax profits over the last year, and warned that trading conditions are tough.
Ian Filby, DFS’s chief executive, told the City this morning:
The UK furniture market continues to be very challenging and the outlook for the sector remains uncertain.
DFS appears to be another victim of weakening consumer confidence, and rising inflation which has pushed up import costs and driven down real wages.
Laith Khalaf, senior analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown, explains:
Big ticket items like sofas tend to be the first things consumers cut back on when they are feeling the pinch, and a slew of poor sales data from the car industry corroborates that trend.
Things don’t look like they are getting much easier either, with DFS expecting weak trading conditions to continue into the next financial year.
The SMMT’s communications director, Tamzen Isacsson, blames economic and political uncertainty for the drop in UK car sales:
New car market down over 9% in Sept now at around 426,000 . Confidence falls with ec and pol uncertainty + confusion over air quality plans
— Tamzen Isacsson (@TamzenIsacsson) October 5, 2017
Reuters has a good explanation of why UK car sales have declined for the last six months:
Sales have fallen year-on-year since April due to a combination of factors including increased vehicle excise duty, weaker consumer confidence, partly due to uncertainty around Brexit, and comparisons with record sales in 2015 and 2016.
Diesel car sales have been worst hit as consumers fear new levies and possible restrictions on their use in urban areas as the government continues to consult on ways to reduce pollution.
Brexit deters investment in UK car industry
SMMT chief Mike Hawes also warns that car manufacturers are putting off new investment until they know what’s happening with Brexit.
Hawes says Britain’s auto industry enjoyed a “tremendous run” of investment, around £2.5bn per year for the last five years.
But.... investment fell by a third in 2016, and is “down markedly again this year, Hawes says.
He blames uncertainty over Britain’s exit from the European Union:
“People are waiting to see what the future relationship with our biggest market, Europe, is going to be before making any additional investment.”
Updated
The agenda: UK car sales suffer September slowdown
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone crisis and business.
Britain’s car industry is facing its first drop in annual sales since 2011, after suffering a sharp drop in demand last month.
Figures due out at 9am today will show that new car registrations fell for the sixth month running in September.
September is usually a bumper month for the industry because licence plates change (meaning motorists can proudly drive away with a ‘brand new car’ to impress the neighbours).
But not this year. Industry experts warn that sales may have fallen by nearly 10% year-on-year in September.
That means there’s now a serious danger that British car sales will shrink in 2017, for the first time since 2011.
Mike Hawes, the head of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, says we should brace for a bad set of figures.
Speaking on that BBC Today Programme, Hawes warns:
Sales have been falling for six months and that trend is probably going to be magnified given the size of the September market.
So we’re probably going to see something over 9% in September.
Hawes blames falling consumer morale, saying:
The confidence that people have in making big-ticket items… is just declining.
He also cites uncertainty over the figure of the car industry itself. Recent warnings from the government that petrol and diesel car sales could be banned by 2040 have left consumers confused.
We’ll bring you the full picture of the UK car industry at 9am today.
Also coming up today...
The Catalan crisis continues to loom over the European financial markets, with speculation that the region could vote on declaring independence next week.
We’ll also be watching the energy sector, following the government’s move to introduce a price cap on bills.
It’s not as simple as that, though, as my colleague Adam Vaughan explains:
Theresa May’s pledge to cap “rip-off” energy prices is about as clear as the average electricity and gas bill.
The prime minister promised to introduce a draft bill next week to give the energy regulator, Ofgem, powers to cap the bills of people being “punished” for their loyalty and their inability to shop around.
But the Conservatives later admitted that they were only giving Ofgem the powers to impose a cap for everyone on a standard variable tariff, not actually ordering the regulator to impose it.....
Here’s the agenda:
- 9am BST: UK car registration figures released by SMMT
- 10am BST: Eurozone retail PMI reports
- 1.30pm BST: US weekly jobless figures
- 3pm BST: US factory orders for August
Updated